See Software Bisque Featured on PBS!
 
Where are the stars in the Trapezium
 


The Trapezium

Related links

  • Additional SDB files back to
  • Instructions for adding SDB files to TheSky
  • Understanding Catalog Capriciousnessfs

  • (click here for animation!) splitting the Trapezium

    Background

    In the past I was frequently asked why TheSky does not contain the 4 to 6 primary stars in the "Trapezium" a well known  "asterism" of stars located in the heart of the Orion Nebula M42 - NGC1976 in the constellation Orion so an explanation is in order. 

     

    The issue does not have to do with TheSky's ability to plot stellar data accurately, nor does it have any thing to do with zoom level limitations (as other competitor's have falsely claimed in the past), but rather with the common stellar catalogs currently available to all planetarium programs.

     

    The four common Trapezium stars are not in included in the GSC data, SAO data, USNO A2.0, UCAC2, or the Hipparcos/Tycho-2 data. Only after plotting the USNO-B1 80 gigabytes of data containing 1 billion stars do the four common stars show. And there are actually more than just the 4 brighter stars in close proximity

     

    To address the problem of the missing stars Software Bisque as added them using TheSky's Database Manager, and has done so for many years (20+), using auxiliary data input.  In fact, this same method is currently been used by most competing planetarium programs now to fill in the missing Trapezium stars.  

    Downloads

    Download the above files and extract them into the default SDB folder,


     ..\Program Files\Software Bisque\TheSky6\Data\User\SDBs\


    Then "Add" the SDB's to the Active List of SDB's using TheSky's Database Manager. Questions?

    TheSky Zoom levels

    In TheSky you can zoom into a field of view as small as 1 arc-minute across the screen. Take the one arc-minute field divided by your screen resolution in pixels and you have the resolution in arc seconds/pixel. For example, a screen resolution of 800 by 600 yields a resolution of 0.075 arc seconds/pixel!

    For even more stellar data TheSky also supports the US Naval Observatory data on a single CD-ROM of 54 millions stars or 11 CD-ROMS containing 526 million stars and now the USNO-B (subset as distributed with TheSky) and the UCAC2 stellar catalog. Provided you have the entire 80 gigabytes with 1 billion stars  USNO-B1 complete to ~21 magnitude these too can be plotted in TheSky

    Because 80 gigabytes is far too much data to re-distribute with TheSky a subset version was carefully created to fit the needs of most if not all of TheSky users.

    CCD image
    trapzium.gif (7527 bytes)
    (c) Mike Palermitti, Jupiter FL
    click image for animation

    TheSky 6 details

    The following screen shot shows TheSky version 6 display with 1.5 billion stars plotted from the USNO-B, USNO A2.0, GSC, Hipparcos/Tycho-2, and UCAC 2.0 data.

     

    Note: Yes, their is redundancy between catalogs as well as discrepancies in position and/or magnitudes.

    TheSky version 6!

    1.5 billion stars plotted!

    Proper Motion Vectors

    What's with the arrow on the middle star?

    If you enable the option to plot those stars that have proper motion data a vector line is drawn indicating direction and amount of motion over the time you specify. Also see the page Barnard's Star for more details using the highest proper motion star for more!

    Enabling Proper Motion vector

    Select number of years to plot

    Following are the additional stars found in the "Trapezium" SDB file included with the latest update to TheSky6
    CLICK HERE to get the most recent update to version 6.

     

    Note the Trapezium stars are not loaded by default. The Trapezium Stars need to be added to the Active List of databases using the Data | Sky Database Manager | Add/Remove option. Step-by-step instructions here.

    More Stars added

    Now the display looks more like the real thing!
    (is it live or Memorex?)

    The Trapezium data file (SDB) is located in the folder

     ..Program Files\Software Bisque\TheSky6\Data\User\SDBs\trapezium.sdb

    along with many other SDB files you can add to the list. Please see the following URL for a description of SDB files and how to add them to your current list. 

    What is an SDB (Sky DataBase) file? or refer to TheSky's manual.

     

    In addition to the error prone and somewhat obsolete now GSC data TheSky6 is now using the Hipparcos/Tycho, UCAC, and USNO-B (a distributed subset of the 80 gigabytes with 1 billion stars) catalogs or any combination. Since all of the SAO catalog of 259,000 stars are included in other stellar catalogs we do not have these redundant data entries but this stellar data is cross referenced to the other stellar catalogs.

     

    For those that wish to plot the SAO catalog I have created an SDB file that allows these stars to be plotted and searched as well. Click here for details on using TheSky Database files (SDB'S)

     

    The Hipparcos/Tycho catalogs are much more accurate in regard to stellar positions (including proper motion) and magnitudes when compared to the now dated GSC data. However, even the Hipparcos/Tycho data contains only a handful of stars ~1 million between, and as with all large data sets even this widely claimed near perfect data is now being found to contain certain many entry errors. Note that it is extremely difficult to maintain any database with thousands of objects like the NGC data or even millions of positions and magnitudes like the Hipparcos/Tycho, GSC, UCAC, USNO-B, USNO A2.0, data.

     

    For additional datasets like the Yale Bright Stars or the SAO catalog see the following.

    More Data!

    Background on the outdated GSC data

    The method used to create the G)uide S)tar C)atalog data was to scan the actual photographic plates and create entries for the stellar positions and magnitudes as seen by the scanning method and complex pattern recognition software designed for the task. This would have not been possible or realistic to have humans do the tedious and arduous task, not to mention that would still be prone to errors!

     

    The GSC stellar data is used by the Hubble Space Telescope for orientation purposes. Note that many of the stellar and non-stellar catalogs that we choose to use in TheSky, yes even the NGC catalog, contain positional errors, magnitude errors, size errors, and even missing data. To this end there was an article written by Stuart Goldman editor of Sky and Telescope regarding these types of catalog errors.

     

    The well written article titled "Understanding Catalog Capriciousness"  printed in  Sky and Telescope magazine can be found reprinted with permission here.

     

    To explain the missing stars in the Trapezium let us first show the actual digitized image of the Great Nebula in Orion M42/NGC 1976 found on the digitized Sky Survey photographic plates.

    Digital Image of M42
    Created in CCDSoft
    trap1.jpg (15871 bytes)
    from the 102 CD-ROM of the  Palomar Sky Survey
    RealSky/DSS Copyright

    Since most of us cannot afford the complete 102 CD-ROM set the Space Telescope Science Institute and the Astronomical Society of the Pacific have made this data affordable and manageable. The compressed 18 volume set of the data known as RealSky (8 CD-ROMS northern Hemisphere and 10 CD-ROMS for the southern). Unfortunately this product has been discontinued and all our requests to obtain the rights to re-distribute the data have gone unanswered.

     

    Using the DSS or RealSky data you have the entire night sky as seen with a 48" telescope complete to 19th magnitude at your finger tips. When RealSky is used in conjunction with TheSky you have a very powerful research tool that can overcome the problems related to cataloged data. Looking at the above image it is easy to see why the normal means of creating data from the plates was susceptible to problems. Take another example, M13 the Great Cluster in Hercules.

    Globular Cluster M13
    Created in CCDSoft
    m13-error.jpg (32427 bytes)
    from the 102 CD-ROM of the Palomar Sky Survey
    RealSky/DSS Copyright

    Based on the images above you can see why there are holes in the bright tight globular clusters or missing stars in the areas where there is a lot of nebulosity. There are some areas like M42 the Great Nebula in Orion or M22 the Globular Cluster in Sagittarius where other methods have been used to fill in the hole of missing stars.

     

    Frankly I was surprised to find that out of the USNO data (550 million stars), SAO data, the GSC data (1.1 and 1.2) data, and the Hipparcos/Tycho-2 data there still aren't all entries for the common 4 to 11+ stars in the Trapezium. The reason I created my own entries for these stars was I have not found a good source for them.

    Where can I get more stars?

    By using an on-line source like the astronomical database Simbad or the NASA Extragalactic Database you can make a query using M42 for the search criteria and request say all stars within 10 arcminutes of the object. Cool!

    Simbad query around M42 plotted by TheSky6

    More stars click on image for complete details!
    Simbad data plotting

    Stellar data Warning! Magnitude = zero Garbage in Garbage out!

    NOTE: If the objects to be compiled are of type stars instead of say object type "reference point" the use of the magnitude is crucial. I have seen datasets that don't have magnitudes only coordinates. Plotting stars that do not have magnitudes associated with them indicates a magnitude zero!

     

    The stars that all have a zero for magnitude will plot extremely large and look completely unrealistic because of this. Better to use object type Reference Point when compiling the data or create your own custom symbol <--- Click here which is magnitude independent and unique.

     

    To demonstrate. The Trapezium in the center of M42 the Orion Nebula asking for all objects within 5 arc minutes of the objects  Plotting the data query from the NASA Extragalactic Data page we get the following when the object type is "star" before compiling the dataset.